Synopsis
After the success
of the first Christmas special it was inevitable that we would see the
Carry Oners on screen again, it’s just a shame that the script provided
by Dave Freeman and Sid Colin wasn’t up to scratch. It was also made
cheaper by being in black and white.
The cast is again top-hole but Freeman’s script never sparkles like
Rothwell’s did for the first one, (and even some of the gags used in
this, re-appear in Carry On Columbus, word for word), so it is a good
job the comedians more than make up for the lack of content in quality.
Being a Christmas special and Rothwell last time using the classic
Christmas theme of Christmas Carol, they have gone this time for Robert
Louis Stephenson’s adventure story, Treasure Island, but s et it on
Christmas Eve.
It is a narrative story more akin to the Carry On films than the
previous Christmas special’s loosely connected sketch format, and has
some good roles for the team.
Sid James takes on the central role of Long John Silver as he searches
for Flint’s hidden treasure, but he is barely furnished with any gags at
all. The plum role goes to Terry Scott as Squire Treyhornay and he is
obviously comfortable in the claustrophobic atmosphere of the TV studios
and live audience. Barbara plays off against him gender-bendering as Jim
Hawkins with Barbara playing the character unconvincingly as a man,
which is intentional.
Although the basic plot is taken straight from Carry On Jack, with the
main characters from that film played by Terry Scott and Barbara
Windsor; it is interwoven in to the Treasure Island plot quite
skilfully.
Charles Hawtrey supports with three smaller roles and is memorable as
Blind Pugh and minces a rare delight in the latter part of the show.
|